Comparative 30-day echocardiographic outcomes of Myval vs. Sapien and Evolut THVs: Insights from LANDMARK Trial

Research output: Contribution to journalResearch articleContributedpeer-review

Contributors

  • Osama Soliman - , Cardiovascular Research Institute Dublin (CVRI) (Author)
  • Elfatih A Hasabo - , Cardiovascular Research Institute Dublin (CVRI) (Author)
  • Niels van Royen - , Radboud University Medical Center (Author)
  • Ignacio J Amat-Santos - , Hospital Clínico Universitario de Valladolid (Author)
  • Martin Hudec - , Central Slovak Institute of Heart and Vascular Diseases (Author)
  • Matjaz Bunc - , University Medical Centre Ljubljana (Author)
  • Alexander IJsselmuiden - , Zuyderland Hospital (Author)
  • Peep Laanmets - , North Estonia Medical Centre (Author)
  • Daniel Unic - , University Hospital Dubrava (Author)
  • Bela Merkely - , Semmelweis University (Author)
  • Renicus S Hermanides - , Isala Hospital Zwolle (Author)
  • Mohamed Mouden - , European Interbalkan Medical Center Thessaloniki (Author)
  • Vlasis Ninios - , European Interbalkan Medical Center Thessaloniki (Author)
  • Marcin Protasiewicz - , Wrocław Medical University (Author)
  • Benno J W M Rensing - , St. Antonius Hospital (Author)
  • Pedro L Martin - , Doctor Negrín University Hospital (Author)
  • Fausto Feres - , Instituto Dante Pazzanese de Cardiologia (Author)
  • Manuel De Sousa Almeida - , NOVA University Lisbon (Author)
  • Eric van Belle - , University Hospital of Lille (Author)
  • Axel Linke - , Department of Internal Medicine and Cardiology (at Dresden Heart Centre) (Author)
  • Alfonso Ielasi - , IRCCS Galeazzi Hospital - Sant'Ambrogio (Author)
  • Matteo Montorfano - , IRCCS Hospital San Raffaele - Milano (Author)
  • Mark Webster - , Auckland City Hospital (Author)
  • Konstantinos Toutouzas - , Hippokration General Hospital — Athens (Author)
  • Emmanuel Teiger - , Hôpital Henri Mondor (Author)
  • Francesco Bedogni - , IRCCS Policlinico San Donato (Author)
  • Michiel Voskuil - , University Medical Center (UMC) Utrecht (Author)
  • Dolores Mesa Rubio - , Hospital Universitario Reina Sofía, Maimónides Institute of Biomedical Research of Cordoba (IMIBIC), CIBER - Cardiovascular Diseases (CIBERCV) (Author)
  • Oskar Angerås - , University of Gothenburg (Author)
  • Won-Keun Kim - , Kerckhoff Clinic (Author)
  • Jürgen Rothe - , University Medical Center Freiburg (Author)
  • Ivica Kristić - , University Hospital Center Split (Author)
  • Vicente Peral - , Balearic Island Health Research Institute (Author)
  • Ben J L Van den Branden - , Amphia Hospital (Author)
  • Ashokkumar Thakkar - , Meril Life Sciences Pvt. Ltd. (Author)
  • Udita Chandra - , Meril Life Sciences Pvt. Ltd. (Author)
  • Dina Neiroukh - , Cardiovascular Research Institute Dublin (CVRI) (Author)
  • Cagri Ayhan - , Cardiovascular Research Institute Dublin (CVRI) (Author)
  • Mahmoud Y Nosir - , University Hospital Galway (Author)
  • Magdi S Yacoub - , Cardiovascular Research Institute Dublin (CVRI) (Author)
  • Sanaa Ali - , Cardiovascular Research Institute Dublin (CVRI) (Author)
  • Mohamad Altamimi - , Cardiovascular Research Institute Dublin (CVRI) (Author)
  • Hesham Elzomor - , University Hospital Galway (Author)
  • Patrick W Serruys - , University Hospital Galway (Author)
  • Andreas Baumbach - , Cleveland Clinic London (Author)

Abstract

INTRODUCTION: Several factors, including device design, annulus size, and sizing strategies, influence transcatheter heart valve (THV) hemodynamic outcomes in patients with aortic stenosis(AS). This substudy evaluates early (30-day) echocardiographic outcomes of the Myval, Sapien, and Evolut THV series, focusing on hemodynamic performance and valve durability.

METHODOLOGY: The LANDMARK trial is a prospective, randomised, multicentre, open-label, non-inferiority trial comparing 384 patients implanted with Myval THV series to 384 receiving Sapien and Evolut THV series. Hemodynamic assessments followed Valve Academic Research Consortium-3 recommendations.

RESULTS: At 30-day, hemodynamic device success rates were 85.9%, 77.8, and 85.4% for Myval, Sapien, and Evolut THV series, respectively (PMyval-Sapien=0.02 and PMyval-Evolut>0.99). Significant improvements in peak aortic flow velocity, pressure gradients, effective orifice area(EOA), Doppler velocity index(DVI), and cardiac indices were observed across all groups, except for unchanged left ventricular ejection fraction. Moderate prosthesis-patient mismatch (PPM) was less frequent with Myval THV series(10.7%) versus Sapien THV series(22.5%), but higher than Evolut THV series (6.0%)(PMyval-Sapien=0.0006, PMyval-Evolut=0.12), while severe PPM showed no significant differences(4.3% vs 6.5% vs 1.8%; PMyval-Sapien=0.40, PMyval-Evolut=0.23). Total aortic regurgitation (≥moderate) showed no significant difference for Myval (2.6%), Sapien(1.8%) or Evolut THV series (6.3%)(PMyval-Sapien=0.76, PMyval-Evolut=0.06). Myval THV series required minimal oversizing compared to Evolut THV series (P<0.0001).

CONCLUSION: The Myval THV series demonstrates short-term hemodynamic performance comparable to Evolut THV series and superior to Sapien THV series in moderate PPM incidence. Including intermediate sizes minimizes oversizing, underscoring its potential as an alternative for TAVI patients. Long-term follow-up is necessary to confirm these findings.

Details

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)247-260
Number of pages14
JournalEuropean heart journal. Cardiovascular imaging
Volume27
Issue number2
Early online date28 Aug 2025
Publication statusPublished - Feb 2026
Peer-reviewedYes

External IDs

unpaywall 10.1093/ehjci/jeaf245
Scopus 105029715348

Keywords

Keywords

  • Aged, Aged, 80 and over, Aortic Valve Stenosis/surgery, Echocardiography, Doppler/methods, Echocardiography/methods, Female, Heart Valve Prosthesis, Hemodynamics/physiology, Humans, Male, Prospective Studies, Prosthesis Design, Time Factors, Transcatheter Aortic Valve Replacement/methods, Treatment Outcome, non-inferiority, echocardiography, TAVI, PPM, stenosis, aortic stenosis, balloon expandable BEV, Myval, aortic valve, THV, haemodynamic, randomized trial, transcatheter heart valve, self expandable SEV, aortic regurgitation, Evolut, Sapien