Carbon sequestration in Plaggic Anthrosols is most often investigated by bulk soil carbon inventories, without considering the form in which the carbon is stored (e.g., particulate or mineral-associated organic matter (OM), its capacity, or its chemical composition). Here, we focus on the unusual high organic carbon (OC) accumulation in sandy Plaggic Anthrosols and adjacent reference soils under agricultural use. In these soils, the mineral fraction ≤20 µm which is commonly assumed to be the major factor for OC stabilization, are very low in mass proportion. Soil organic matter (SOM) physical fractionation was done to evaluate the quantity and quality of OC in the topsoil (Ap horizon). For the fraction ≤20 µm (medium and fine silt-, and clay-sized particles), we measured the concentration of OC and calculated its OC storage capacity and contribution. The OC of the fraction ≤20 µm was radiocarbon-dated and analyzed for its chemical composition by solid-state ¹³C NMR spectroscopy. The highly sandy (∼90 % sand and coarse silt) soils showed an accumulation of OC much higher than the conventionally calculated saturation level controlled by the proportion of the fraction ≤20 µm. Unexpectedly, Plaggic Anthrosols and the respective reference soils showed similar fractional OC concentrations, radiocarbon ages, and OM composition. The isolated fraction ≤20 µm contained, on average, 81 % of the total soil OC in only 9 % of the corresponding soil mass. All soil fractions ≤20 µm are characterized by a high mean OC concentration in the topsoil (reference soils: 226 ± 66.5 mg OC g⁻¹, Plaggic Anthrosols: 202 ± 59.0 mg OC g⁻¹) with a C/N ratio of 15 on average for both soils. The OM composition of the fraction ≤20 µm was specifically rich in alkyl-C, with unusually low proportions of O-alkyl-C and low contents of aryl-C. The radiocarbon concentration (F¹⁴C) indicated that topsoil OM of the ≤20 µm fraction is stored for long time periods with high mean conventional radiocarbon ages (¹⁴C) not only for Plaggic Anthrosols (F¹⁴C: 0.92 ± 0.04; ¹⁴C: 639 yBP) but also for the reference soils (F¹⁴C: 0.93 ± 0.04; ¹⁴C: 575 yBP) and received low inputs of OC derived from recent photosynthesis. Our data indicate the existence of specific SOM accumulation processes in the investigated sandy agricultural soils, resulting particularly large SOM stocks which cannot be explained by mechanistic association of OM with mineral surfaces. It is not clear, if this inherited OM is stable under present-day soil and management conditions.