Tubes or Ribbons? Comparing Texture‐space Visualization for Multivariate Line Data
Research output: Contribution to journal › Research article › Contributed › peer-review
Contributors
Abstract
Multivariate line data is critical for analyzing flow fields, agent systems, and dynamic trajectories. Embedding secondary variables along spatial paths using surface-based primitives such as ribbons and circular tubes introduces challenges related to perspective, scale, and distortion. Perceptual trade-offs due to these challenges remain unclear. We address this gap through a controlled user study with 10 experts in computational fluid dynamics and visualization, performing four identical analysis tasks involving both spatial (requiring location-based relationships) and non-spatial (requiring attribute value comparisons) aspects. The tasks were performed using a prototype with interactivity limited to controlling the camera. While quantitative measures showed no significant performance differences between embedded visualizations on ribbons and tubes, we found a clear subjective preference for tubes among the study participants. Furthermore, their feedback indicates surface-based embeddings are generally helpful and should be utilized more often.
Details
| Original language | English |
|---|---|
| Article number | e70441 |
| Journal | Computer graphics forum |
| Publication status | E-pub ahead of print - 17 Jun 2026 |
| Peer-reviewed | Yes |
External IDs
| ORCID | /0000-0002-2176-876X/work/218582141 |
|---|---|
| ORCID | /0000-0002-0466-2445/work/218582267 |