In this work, we present a template-based preparation of iron oxide-containing hydrogels (ferrogels) with ionic sensitive and superparamagnetic properties. The influence of the cross-linked template polyacrylamide and the concentration of the iron salts and sodium hydroxide on the precipitation of the iron oxide particles is investigated with respect to the stability of the ferrogels. Scanning electron microscope images show cubic particles, which can be semiquantitatively classified in three groups of particle size with respect to the dilution level. Magnetic hysteresis curves reveal a sigmoidal shape without remanence and coercivity for all samples. The higher cross-linked ferrogels, in comparison with the lower cross-linked ferrogels, possess a steady-state degree of swelling in ultrapure water and a stimuli-sensitive deswelling over a wide range of varying ionic strengths. Thus, they are suitable candidates for applications in sensing and microfluidics.