Basic emotions evoked by odors are predominantly related to happiness and disgust as two opposite sides of a continuum, and few studies concerned a wider spectrum of emotions. The present study aimed to investigate whether exposure to a pleasant and an unpleasant odor—compared with the odor-neutral control condition—elicits a change in the emotional state that has a measurable effect on facial expressions in terms of four basic emotions: anger, happiness, sadness, and surprise. 167 participants were randomly divided into two groups and presented with a set of three odors per group (fish, rose, and water/peach, tar, and water), with one odor used per session. This way, each participant took part in three odor sessions that consisted of two tasks. The ‘passive task’ was to passively sniff the odor for 30 seconds; the ‘reading task’ was to stay exposed to the odor while reading out silently a short text. Participants’ facial behavior was recorded. Consistently through all time periods and both tasks, odors of fish/tar and rose/peach were noted to evoke more surprise and sadness than the presentation of water. Anger was elicited to a greater extent by the presentation of water than by the odors of fish/tar and rose/peach. None of the investigated odors evoked happiness. Interestingly, the impact of the task on facial expressions of emotions appears to be marginal. We suggest that how odors elicit emotions might be more complex than typically assumed.