In the Bale Mountains, the ericaceous belt ranges between 3200 and 3800 m asl. Studies indicate an expansion on the Sanetti Plateau at the end of the Late Glacial and during the early Holocene. Currently, only patches of Erica growing between boulders are found on the Plateau, while most of the landscape above 3800 m asl is covered by afro-alpine plants. Driving factors for Erica patches above the upper ericaceous ecotone is a matter of debate. This study evaluates site variables and biogeochemical properties of soils under Erica patches and nearby Erica-free control to understand the environmental conditions responsible for the patchy occurrence of Erica on the Sanetti Plateau. Except for the boulder richness, Erica and control plots have comparable topography, soil texture, and electrical conductivity. However, soils below Erica patches have higher total organic carbon, nitrogen, carbon-to-nitrogen ratios, and black carbon contents than the control plots indicating fresh organic matter input and availability of combustible fuel. This implies that Erica did not fully cover the control plots in former times. Carbon and nitrogen stocks were slightly higher in control plots due to the lower stone contents of the profiles. In addition, soils of the Erica plots showed more positive δ¹³C values than the control soils, possibly attributed to water stress. In general, the relief and soil conditions of control plots may support the growth of Erica. However, Erica growing between boulders seems to benefit from the favorable microclimate and physical protection against grazing and fire.