Bridging the Energy Balance Gap in Eddy-Covariance Measurements: Insights From Standardized Network Data

Research output: Contribution to journalResearch articleContributedpeer-review

Contributors

  • Giacomo Nicolini - , Euro-Mediterranean Center on Climate Change (Author)
  • David Durden - , National Ecological Observatory Network (Author)
  • Luca Di Fiore - , Euro-Mediterranean Center on Climate Change (Author)
  • Christopher Florian - , National Ecological Observatory Network (Author)
  • Simone Sabbatini - , Euro-Mediterranean Center on Climate Change (Author)
  • Bert Gielen - , University of Antwerp (Author)
  • Arne Iserbyt - , University of Antwerp (Author)
  • Benjamin Loubet - , Université Paris-Saclay (Author)
  • Ivan Mammarella - , University of Helsinki (Author)
  • Adriana Mariotti - , Euro-Mediterranean Center on Climate Change (Author)
  • Maarten Op de Beeck - , University of Antwerp (Author)
  • Caleb Slemmons - , National Ecological Observatory Network (Author)
  • Carlo Trotta - , Euro-Mediterranean Center on Climate Change (Author)
  • Adam Young - , National Ecological Observatory Network (Author)
  • Abad Chabbi - , Université Paris-Saclay, INRAE - National Institute of Agricultural Research (Author)
  • Iris Feigenwinter - , ETH Zurich (Author)
  • Bernard Heinesch - , University of Liege (Author)
  • Natalia Kowalska - , Czech Academy of Sciences (Author)
  • Matthias Mauder - , Chair of Meteorology (Author)
  • Ladislav Šigut - , Czech Academy of Sciences (Author)
  • Michiel van der Molen - , Wageningen University & Research (WUR) (Author)
  • Flavio Bastos Campos - , Helmholtz Centre for Environmental Research (Author)
  • Daniel Berveiller - , Université Paris-Saclay (Author)
  • Christian Brümmer - , Johann Heinrich von Thunen Institute (Author)
  • Matthias Cuntz - , Université de Lorraine (Author)
  • Jean Christophe Domec - , INRAE - National Institute of Agricultural Research, College of William and Mary, Duke University (Author)
  • Benjamin Dumont - , University of Liege (Author)
  • Silvano Fares - , National Research Council of Italy (CNR) (Author)
  • Damiano Gianelle - , Istituto Agrario San Michele all'Adige (Edmund Mach Foundation) (Author)
  • Rasmus Jensen - , Aarhus University (Author)
  • Carmen Kalalian - , Université Paris-Saclay (Author)
  • Natascha Kljun - , Lund University (Author)
  • Holger Lange - , Norwegian Institute of Bioeconomy Research (Author)
  • Jean Marc Limousin - , University of Montpellier (Author)
  • Erik Lundin - , Abisko Scientific Research Station (Author)
  • Antonio Manco - , National Research Council of Italy (CNR) (Author)
  • Leonardo Montagnani - , Free University of Bozen-Bolzano (Author)
  • Eiko Nemitz - , Centre for Ecology and Hydrology (Author)
  • Matthias Peichl - , Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences (Author)
  • Erkka Rinne - , Finnish Meteorological Institute (Author)
  • Marilyn Roland - , University of Antwerp (Author)
  • Marius Schmidt - , Institute of Bio- and Geosciences Agrosphere (Author)
  • Guillaume Simioni - , INRAE - National Institute of Agricultural Research (Author)
  • Abin Thomas - , University of Helsinki (Author)
  • Caroline Vincke - , Université catholique de Louvain (Author)
  • Dario Papale - , Tuscia University (Author)

Abstract

The lack of energy balance closure in Eddy-Covariance (EC) measurements is a well-known, still unresolved challenge in micrometeorology, with energy balance closure (EBC) rates typically ranging between 60% and 80%. While numerous hypotheses have been proposed to explain this imbalance, the relative contributions of neglected energy storage terms, data quality and flux processing options remain insufficiently disentangled. Using standardized ICOS and NEON datasets, we show that a significant portion of the observed energy imbalance can be attributed to overlooked or inconsistently handled energy components and turbulent flux quality control. Using data drawn from 84 sites, we show that comprehensive energy accounting—including soil heat flux, storage terms (soil, air, biomass), photosynthetic energy demand, and strict quality filtering of turbulent fluxes—improved EBC by 16% on average, with site-specific gains up to 40%. However, we also identify a persistent residual imbalance that is unlikely to be resolved through methodological refinements or additional measurements alone, pointing to fundamental physical processes that are not accounted for in the standard measurement and processing. We argue that this unresolved imbalance should be explicitly acknowledged and bounded, rather than implicitly absorbed into correction schemes, and we outline practical guidance for diagnosing and interpreting EBC in standardized flux networks. This perspective evaluates methodological advances and residual uncertainties, providing an actionable framework for the appropriate use of EC energy fluxes in carbon, water, and climate research.

Details

Original languageEnglish
Article numbere70892
JournalGlobal change biology
Volume32
Issue number5
Publication statusPublished - May 2026
Peer-reviewedYes

External IDs

PubMed 42080209

Keywords

Keywords

  • eddy covariance, energy balance closure, FLUXNET, ICOS, NEON, standardization