All Cretans lie: Pieter Bruegel’s "Misanthrope" in a new interpretation

Research output: Contribution to book/conference proceedings/anthology/reportChapter in book/anthology/reportContributed

Contributors

Abstract

The following essay provides a close reading of Pieter Bruegel the Elder’s painting The Misanthrope [Fig. 14.1] from 1568. The large-format picture is part of his late work and was paint only one year before his death. The theology of that time forms the context of my interpretation. In particular, Sebastian Franck’s writing Paradoxa from 1534 is my point of reference for the interpretation of the Naples painting. The German theologian was one of the most popular authors of the time in the Netherlands. H. Bonger and A.J. Gelderblom, looking at the research, note that between 1558 and 1621 translations of seventeen major and minor writings of the theologian were made, more than of Luther or Calvin. Franck’s spiritualistic thinking was of the greatest influence.1 So within the framework of existing research, reference was made to this source early on and almost all the texts of the German theologian’s were available for Bruegel in Dutch translation from the middle of the 16th century onwards. The concept of scepticism serves me in two ways to specify my interpretive project. Firstly, it denotes doubt about the cognitive performance of seeing and enables a self-reflection of the medium of the image. Secondly, it helps us to focus on a hermeneutic practice that is co-determined by doubt insofar as Bruegel’s pictorial programmes can contain hidden critical commentaries in relation to the Catholic Church.

Details

Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationImago and Contemplatio in the Visual Arts and Literature (1400–1700)
EditorsStijn Bussels, Karl A. E. Enenkel, Michael Weemans, Elliott D. Wise
PublisherBrill
Pages299-315
Number of pages17
ISBN (electronic)978-90-04-68264-1
ISBN (print)978-90-04-68263-4
Publication statusPublished - 2024
Peer-reviewedNo

Publication series

SeriesIntersections : interdisciplinary studies in early modern culture
Volume88

External IDs

Mendeley fc5d2b65-8910-303a-8ce5-e7bf2a48511b

Keywords