Changes in axonal myelination are an important hallmark of aging and a number of neurological diseases. Demyelinated axons are impaired in their function and degenerate over time. Oligodendrocytes, the cells responsible for myelination of axons, are sensitive to mechanical properties of their environment. Growing evidence indicates that mechanical properties of demyelinating lesions are different from the healthy state and thus have the potential to affect myelinating potential of oligodendrocytes. We performed a high-resolution spatial mapping of the mechanical heterogeneity of demyelinating lesions using atomic force microscope-enabled indentation. Our results indicate that the stiffness of specific regions of mouse brain tissue is influenced by age and degree of myelination. Here we specifically demonstrate that acquired acute but not genetic demyelination leads to decreased tissue stiffness, which could influence the remyelination potential of oligodendrocytes. We also demonstrate that specific brain regions have unique ranges of stiffness in white and grey matter. Our ex vivo findings may help the design of future in vitro models to mimic the mechanical environment of the brain in healthy and diseased states. The mechanical properties of demyelinating lesions reported here may facilitate novel approaches in treating demyelinating diseases such as multiple sclerosis. Statement of Significance: Mechanical characteristics of a cell's environment can have a profound influence on its biological properties. Neuronal and glial cells are sensitive to mechanical input during development, in disease and regeneration. Sustained tensile strain can promote differentiation of oligodendrocyte progenitor cells into mature oligodendrocytes, which are responsible for the myelination of axons. Changing myelination is an important hallmark in human aging and disease, such as multiple sclerosis. Our hypothesis is that these diseases might be characterized by altered tissue stiffness and that this has an influence on remyelination potential. Here we investigate tissue stiffness profiles of healthy, aged and disease model mice. Manipulating the tissue stiffness might be another promising approach for new treatments.