The energy splits, which are used in phase‐field fracture and eigenfracture, are frequently motivated by the statement that crack nucleation and crack growth have to be prevented at compression loads. The intention of the article at hand is to show that the energy decomposition is an essential part of such fracture models, and to investigate the underlying problem and its physical interpretation. Finally, a general framework for the derivation of physically motivated energy splits is presented, which is not limited to certain bulk material models.